TL;DR. Both $95 travel cards with surprisingly comparable feature sets. Autograph Journey earns 5x on flights, 4x on hotels, 3x dining, 1x everything else and includes a $50 airline credit. Sapphire Preferred earns 5x on Chase Travel, 3x dining, 3x streaming, 3x online groceries, and 2x on other travel. CSP has the deeper and better-known transfer partner list (Hyatt, United, Air Canada). Autograph Journey added 6 transfer partners in 2024 (Flying Blue, Avianca LifeMiles, BA Avios, Iberia, Aer Lingus, Choice). Both are excellent at $95.
The three dimensions that actually decide it. First, transfer partners. CSP has Hyatt; Autograph Journey does not. Hyatt is the single most valuable transfer partner in U.S. credit cards. Second, flight earn. Autograph Journey's 5x on flights direct from airlines beats CSP's 5x Chase Travel (which requires booking through the portal). Third, credits. CSP has a $50 Chase Travel hotel credit. Autograph Journey has a $50 airline credit. Both effectively halve the fee.
Real customer scenario for each. If you redeem for Hyatt awards (4k to 15k point cat 1-4 free nights), CSP is correct. If instead you primarily book flights direct from airlines and want 5x on those, Autograph Journey is the better earner. The 5x flights direct is genuinely class-leading at $95.
The trap to avoid. Picking Autograph Journey because the earn rates look slightly better on paper without checking whether Wells Fargo's transfer partner list covers your goal redemptions. No Hyatt, no United, no Delta. Air France/KLM Flying Blue is useful but only for trans-Atlantic.